Judicial control over the expropriation of lands for irrigation projects (a comparative study)
Abstract
Judicial oversight of administration procedures in general constitutes an important factor in legal security, as without such oversight, the administration may deliberately or unintentionally make decisions arbitrarily, which leads to damage to the rights of individuals. In the field of appropriation, the presence of such Censorship is a necessary and vital matter because it is linked to one of the most important original rights established by the canons and laws, regardless of their intellectual and ideological orientations, which is the right to property. Therefore, in this research, we shed light on the judicial oversight in Iraq and the countries under comparison (France and Egypt),
and it became clear to us that the oversight of appropriation decisions in France is subject to two types of oversight, the first is the oversight of legality and the second is the oversight of the budget and a theoretical awareness of the creations of the French State Council. In Egypt, there is judicial control over expropriation decisions represented in the control of legality and control of proportionality. In Iraq, expropriation decisions are subject to legality control only, which is the control that responds to the external administrative decision pillars only. As for decisions to expropriate lands for irrigation projects, given that there is a law An independent authority specialized in the appropriation of these lands is the amended Irrigation Projects Implementation Law No. 138 of 1971. There is no judicial oversight of any kind regarding these decisions because there is a text in the law that prevents the courts from hearing the lawsuit resulting from its application, which indicates an important deficiency in it. At the end of this research, we found many Results and proposals that we hope will make their way to the stakeholders.
