Root-Finding , Analysis and Criticism of the Insults and Affronts of Ahl al -Bayt’s Opponents

Abstract

Among the Shiite hadith sources, there is a saying that the Ahl al-Bayt of the Prophet (PBUH) were ordered to insult their opponents. This concept is found in the phrase: “We, the community of Banu Hashim, command our elders and our children to insult them and disavow them.” Kashi mentioned this saying for the first time in the fourth century AH in his book Al-Rijali, and until the twelfth century, no trace of this phrase could be found in novel books, until the twelfth century by news scholars in the books of the worlds of science, Bihar al-Anwar and Riyadh al-Anwar. Revealing it again from Rijal al-Kashi, with a slight difference. The hadith is turbulent, and this phrase is the saying of Sayed Al-Hamiri from the Kaisani sect and not from the infallible Imam. In addition, in the series of narrations, there are people like Nasr bin Sabbah, Ishaq bin Muhammad Basri, and Muhammad bin Jumhur Ammi among the ghulat. Since there is in the thinking of the Kisanis and extremists the phenomenon of cursing the opponents of the Ahl al-Bayt (), it is possible to judge the weakness and weakness in the phrase “We, the clans of Banu Hashim, order our elders and our children to insult them and disavow them.” In addition, the content of the phrase contradicts the verses of the Qur'an and the accounts of the infallible.